FIFO, LIFO, and SIRO: What is the Pros and Cons of different types of Queue Systems

In the bustling world of Australian business, from the local bakery in Fremantle to a major service centre in Brisbane, customers are constantly forming queues. While we often think of queues as simply "waiting in line," the underlying method by which customers are served can dramatically impact efficiency, fairness, and overall customer satisfaction.

Understanding the different types of queue systems – FIFO, LIFO, and SIRO – is crucial for any Australian business or public sector entity looking to optimise its customer flow. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses, and choosing the right one can make all the difference.

Let's dive into the pros and cons of these fundamental queuing models, keeping the Australian context in mind.

1. FIFO (First In, First Out)

What it is

FIFO is the most common and intuitive queuing discipline. As the name suggests, the first customer to join the queue is the first customer to be served. Think of a single line at a supermarket checkout or waiting for your number to be called at a doctor's surgery.

Pros for Australian Businesses

Cons for Australian Businesses

Perceived Fairness (The "Fair Go" Principle)

This is the biggest advantage, especially in Australia, where fairness and equality are highly valued. Customers appreciate knowing that their turn is genuinely next and that no one is jumping the queue. This reduces anxiety and frustration.

Long Waits for Complex Tasks

If the first few customers require very long service times (e.g., complex banking transactions, detailed consultations), subsequent customers, even those needing quick service, are stuck waiting. This can lead to high abandonment rates for simple queries.

Simplicity and Predictability

It's easy for both customers and staff to understand. The order is clear, making wait time estimations more straightforward.

Idle Staff

If specific staff members are trained for different tasks, or if a particular service point becomes free, it might remain idle even if customers needing that specific service are further down the queue.

Reduces Conflicts

With a clear, objective system, arguments or perceived favouritism are minimised, creating a calmer environment for staff and customers.

Limited Flexibility

It doesn't allow for prioritisation of urgent cases (without breaking the rule) or routing customers to specific service types easily.

Easy to Implement (Manually or with Basic QMS)

A simple single line or a basic ticket system naturally follows FIFO.

2. LIFO (Last In, First Out)

What it is

LIFO is the opposite of FIFO. The last customer to join the queue is the first one to be served. This is less common for typical customer service lines and is usually seen in very specific contexts where the "last in" is most accessible.

Pros for Australian Businesses

Cons for Australian Businesses

Speed for Latest Arrivals

Can be very fast for newly arriving customers if the service point is immediately accessible.

Highly Unfair (and Infuriating) for Customers

This system fundamentally contradicts customer expectations of fairness. People who have been waiting longer will be extremely frustrated to see new arrivals served first.

Specific Niche Applications

It has very specific uses, such as retrieving items from a stacked pile where the most recent addition is on top (e.g., a delivery truck unloading specific items).

High Abandonment Rates

Customers will quickly leave if they perceive the system as unfair or if their wait time is constantly being pushed back by new arrivals.

Very Limited Applicability

Rarely suitable for human-centric service queues where patience is a factor. You won't find this at an Australian post office!

3. SIRO (Service In Random Order)

What it is

SIRO means customers are served in a completely random order, regardless of when they arrived. There's no systematic sequence; it's like picking names out of a hat.

Pros for Australian Businesses

Cons for Australian Businesses

Potentially Very Fast for Some

A few lucky customers might get served almost instantly, creating a positive, albeit random, experience for them.

Extremely Unfair and Frustrating

Like LIFO, SIRO is deeply unsatisfying for customers who perceive no logical reason for the waiting order. It violates the basic expectation of fairness.

Simple if No Control Mechanism

If there's no system in place at all, human error or pure chance can sometimes lead to SIRO.

Chaos and Complaints

Will inevitably lead to widespread customer complaints, arguments, and a perception of disorganisation.

Difficult to Manage

Without a system, it's chaotic. With a system, randomly selecting customers is technically possible but socially damaging.

Poor for Staff Morale

Staff often bear the brunt of customer frustration in such an unorganised system.

Choosing the Right Queue System for Your Australian Operations

For the vast majority of Australian businesses and public sector entities dealing with customer-facing queues, FIFO (First In, First Out) is the clear winner for its fairness, predictability, and general acceptance.

However, modern Queue Management Systems often incorporate elements that enhance FIFO or offer intelligent variations:

Choosing the Right Queue System for Your Australian Operations

Priority Queues Allowing VIPs or urgent cases (e.g., medical emergencies, pregnant women) to bypass the main FIFO queue. This is about managed exceptions, not random chaos.

Skill-Based Routing Customers are routed to the first available staff member qualified to handle their specific query, even if they weren't strictly next in the overall line. This is still generally fair as it optimises the service rather than just the wait.

Appointment Systems Customers pre-book times, effectively creating many small, managed FIFO queues for specific time slots.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the theoretical models of FIFO, LIFO, and SIRO exist, the practical application for customer service in Australia overwhelmingly favours FIFO due to its alignment with fairness expectations. The real innovation lies in how modern QMS technology can refine and optimise this principle, making the FIFO experience smoother, more transparent, and ultimately, more satisfying for everyone.

FAQs

Queue Management System

What do FIFO, LIFO, and SIRO stand for in queue management?

FIFO: First In, First Out (the first person to join the queue is the first to be served). LIFO: Last In, First Out (the last person to join the queue is the first to be served). SIRO: Service In Random Order (customers are served in no particular sequence).

Which queue system is most commonly used for customer service and why?

FIFO (First In, First Out) is by far the most commonly used system for customer service. This is primarily because it is perceived as the fairest and most equitable method, aligning with customer expectations that those who wait longer should be served sooner.

What are the main benefits of using a FIFO queue system?

The main benefits of FIFO include high perceived fairness and transparency for customers, which reduces frustration and complaints. It's also simple for both customers and staff to understand and follow, making the process predictable and generally leading to a calmer waiting environment.

How does a Queue Management System help implement or refine these queue types?

A QMS provides the technology to implement and manage these types more effectively. For FIFO, it automates ticket dispensing, digital displays, and notifications. For variations, it provides software for priority routing, skill-based assignment, and comprehensive data analytics to continually optimize the chosen queue model.

Level Up Your Business with Smarter Queue Management

Take your customer experience to the next level with our smart, all-in-one queue system. Whether you're online or on-site, we've got you covered.

Find your nearest branch or chat with us today — and see the impact on your operations and satisfaction instantly.